Monday, November 16, 2009

Designer Babies - Like It Or Not, Here They Come

Is It Morally Right To Let Couples Choose The Genes Of Their Children





Long before 21st century, people envisioned with both, horror and hope, a day when babies could be custom designed - free of inherited diseases, yet equipped with desirable characteristics of the parents. "Designer babies" is a term used by the media and the journalists to describe this soothing yet frightening scenario.



But this frightening scenario is slowly and steadily taking a strong and definite shape in the western world. The Fertility Institutes in New York, Los Angles and Mexico recently stunned the community by being the first one to boldly offer couples the opportunity to screen their embryos not only for diseases but also for gender and other characteristics like eye color, hair color and complexion. The institute proudly claims that it is and will continue to facilitate and provide new, almost any conceivable customization as science makes them available. As couples arrive from around the globe flocking in doors to pay the institute their life's savings for a custom designed baby, opponents hold responsible the institute for shattering moral and ethical boundaries.



Is the institute really accountable and can it really be blamed for shattering moral boundaries? Or is it the "trend" of the western world? Is it the necessity or helplessness of one? Or is it a competition between two?


The answer lies within our own heart and faith. What is morally right or wrong for one might not necessarily be right or wrong for another. Everyone has their own opinions and necessities. If the technology, and research is used in the right manner, that is to help the couples who are actually at a high risk of conceiving a child who can inherit diseases from which the child has a risk of dying very young or even before being born, or to help those who are at a risk of conceiving one with disability, then it could be said to being used in a moral manner. If it is used in the manner of choosing desirable characteristics within a child that the couple wants, like blue eyes and blond hair, then it could said to be going against the moral conduct. Just because they want their child to have their desired characteristics, they are taking away the uniqueness of the child in their hand just to fulfill some of their wishes.



Couples considering this way of "genetic enhancement" should elaborate in thinking about the rights and wrongs about it. Being it very expensive, they need to think about their financial status and what effect will it have on other people who are not a financial status of affording it. They need to think about how their child's behaviour be toward those without genetic enhancement. They need to think about the high risk that is involved in these kinds of experiments. they need to think about all the options, concerns and risks involved in these genetic enhancement experiments.








For some it might be a necessity. But for some it could only be a competition that could put their future child's life at risk. Parents need to think about their child before they actually think about their own desires. Because right can be wrong and wrong can be right for anyone, according to their circumstances. Well, what ever it is, the future will indeed be interesting.



Genetic Enhancement Cartoon

Sources:

http://www.bionetonline.org/English/content/db_cont1.htm

http://www.bionetonline.org/English/content/db_eth.htm

http://www.fertility-docs.com/

http://www.fertility-docs.com/fertility_gender.phtml?PHPSESSID=5e957af3bceb31870e64ca28ef815b09

http://scientificamerican.com/media/inline/regulate-designer-babies_1.jpg

http://www.k21.files.wordpress.com/2009/02/designer_baby_babies.jpg


Blogs commented on:

http://yurisbioblog.blogspot.com/

http://bluegreenteal.blogspot.com/


4 comments:

  1. GREAT VISUALS!!!! I totally agree with you. If parents want to save the child from a genetical disorder this technology will be the life saviour. On the other hand, if the parents want to genetically modify the child for its cosmetic charecterstics then it will challenge the uniqueness of the child. This will also cause us to lose our ethnical and social values and we will not give importance to the creation of God. designing babies according to the wish if the parent will cause challenge the the individuallism of the child.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree completely with what you say, Neelum. The up side of 'designing' a baby is that we can cure and prevent diseases. Yet, why would we want to alter DNA's? Shouldn't we just accept how things are supposed to originally play out? There's a reason for everything. Sure, it would be nice to live life without watching our children go through difficulties and suffering, but life is composed of and created from all the hardships that we endure. The end result if we choose to go down this path will be as you stated, just a competition. We will all soon go crazy with the alteration of genes, and this will all just be one whole competition on who has the better looking child. Why would we allow ourselves to live in a world like this? We need to embrace the uniqueness that we were originally meant to have, and not try to change it, but embrace it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Neelum!

    I'd like to start of by saying that I like your selection of pictures for this blog.

    Moving on, it is frightening to see that there are some parents out there who want to use this technology for cosmetic purposes only and not medical purposes. I agree that by wanting certain characteristics from your child, you are taking away the uniqeuness of your own child just so that you can fulfill some of your own wishes. This may be viewed as ethical to some people and not ethical to others. Regardless, couples should definetly review the rights and the wrongs about this technology before proceeding into it because there are so many.

    Parents should be thankful and appreciative of the new life that God has given them. Without question, we should also be thankful to God for allowing us to share the similar physical traits that run in our families. Nature and its diveristy is what's beautiful. I believe that it is ethical to use designer babies for medical purposes ONLY and not for cosmetic ones!

    It would indeed be interesting to see in what direction this technology will go in the future. All in all, I enjoyed reading your blog!
    -Savia

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Neelum i really like your blog however i think you should have explained more about in vitro fertilization just in case your audience are not sure about it. i think it would help give your audience a brief idea referring to what your talking about in the beginning. overall i love your visuals and i totally agree with you, humans should be proud of who and what kind of DNA they receive. i mean like it's alright if we are using this method to cure diseases but to alter our DNA for our own desire. however i am interested to see the future of people who are designer babies. ^.^

    ReplyDelete